BMI and Children

There is currently no universally accepted system for the classification of childhood obesity. Across the world numerous Body Mass Index (BMI) classification systems are in operation, giving rise to a plethora of definitions arising from the diversity in sample size, nationality of reference populations, and use of different obesity cut points. For example, in the USA, the CDC 2000 centile charts (developed from a USA reference population) are used to establish overweight and obesity in individuals exceeding the 85th and 95th centile respectively. In the UK, the UK1990 reference charts (developed from a British reference population) are used to define overweight and obesity in individuals exceeding the 91st and 98th centiles when used within a clinical setting, and 85th and 95th centiles when used for population monitoring. The International Obesity Task Force (IOTF), on the other hand, have proposed an international definition based on data from six different countries, with cut points extrapolated from the adult BMI cut points of 25kg/m2 and 30kg/m2 for overweight and obesity at age 187,8. In addition, the World Health Organisation (WHO), have also released their new growth standards, in response to global surge in childhood obesity and the release of the new international growth standards for infants and preschool children.

Currently three BMI classification systems are available to the UK and are reviewed in Table 3.

Table 3: A Summary Comparison of the UK 1990, IOTF and WHO Definitions for Childhood Body Mass Index

UK 1990 IOTF WHO 2007
Reference population size
(dates of collection)
15,636 males & 14,899 females
(1978-1990)
97,876 males & 94,851 females
(1963-1993)
15,103 males & 14,915 females
(NGRS 1997-2003) & (NCHS: 1963-1974)
Reference age range 0-23 years 2-18 years 0-19 years
Geography of reference population
UK population only
International population: UK, Brazil, Hong Kong, Netherlands, Singapore and the USA. A combination of the USA National Centre for Health Statistics 1977 pooled growth data and the WHO Multi-centre Growth Reference Study (MGRS) from Brazil, Ghana, Norway, India, Oman, USA
Methodology Distribution based approach whereby overweight and obesity are defined by exceeding the 85th and 95th centiles for population monitoring and 91st and 98th centiles for clinical measurement. Age and sex specific cut points that are extrapolated from the adult BMI cut points of 25kg/m2 and 30kg/m2 for overweight and obesity respectively. Distribution based approach where by centile curves were also modelled to align with the WHO child growth standards at 5 years and the recommended adult BMI cut points of 25kg/m2 and 30kg/m2 for overweight and obesity at age 19.
Fit with adult BMI cut points No Yes at age 18
Yes at age 19
Copyright issues Reference data owned by the Child Growth Foundation. Data published. Data published.
Definition for underweight No agreed definition for underweight although lower centiles are published. Definition for underweight published Lower centiles are published.
Ethnic / cultural variation No Yes Yes
Comparability with other countries No Yes Yes
Current uses
  • Health Survey for England
  • The NCMP (formally NCOD)
  • Recommended by the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health within in a clinical setting for children 2-17 years.
  • NICE and SIGN
  • This approach will be used by WHO for international comparisons.
  • Recommended by SACN (Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition) and RCPCH in their September 2007 report for use between 2 weeks and 2 years.

Tags: age groups | bmi | body image | body mass index | body measurements | boys | child development | child health | child nutrition | child poverty | children | eating disorders | girls | infant nutrition | infants | nutrition | obesity | overweight | physiology | toddlers | weight | young people